• Latest

If Only Rating Agencies Could Talk Turkey

25 May, 2012
China Liberal Education Holdings Limited Starts Higher Volume Production and Expands Domestic Sales Channels of All-in-one Machine AI-Space

China Liberal Education Holdings Limited Starts Higher Volume Production and Expands Domestic Sales Channels of All-in-one Machine AI-Space

19 December, 2020
Bell connecting Canadians at home for the holidays with free TV programming and no extra usage fees on residential Internet

Bell connecting Canadians at home for the holidays with free TV programming and no extra usage fees on residential Internet

18 December, 2020
TEMSA: Bus exports to be delivered to the heart of the European Union

TEMSA: Bus exports to be delivered to the heart of the European Union

18 December, 2020
EU tries to reshape the rules of the Internet

EU tries to reshape the rules of the Internet

17 December, 2020
Matterport Brings 3D Capture to the iPhone

Matterport Brings 3D Capture to the iPhone

5 May, 2020
NASA Administrator Statement on Agency Coronavirus Status

NASA Administrator Statement on Agency Coronavirus Status

15 March, 2020
Technology Supports Social Distancing in age of Covid-19

Technology Supports Social Distancing in age of Covid-19

15 March, 2020
Second Staff Exchange Between EU CyberSecurity Organizations

Second Staff Exchange Between EU CyberSecurity Organizations

19 February, 2020
Iranian Professor on the Iran-US escalation: “Iranians expected to hear a clear and steadfast condemnation from Turkish authorities over Soleimani’s death”

Iranian Professor on the Iran-US escalation: “Iranians expected to hear a clear and steadfast condemnation from Turkish authorities over Soleimani’s death”

16 February, 2020
Badly Trained Spam – Only A Quarter of Brits Train their Spam Filter

Badly Trained Spam – Only A Quarter of Brits Train their Spam Filter

6 February, 2020
Year 2020: What is the Status of 5G Rollout Worldwide and Turkey

Year 2020: What is the Status of 5G Rollout Worldwide and Turkey

31 January, 2020
Turkish Competition Authority’s Android Decision

Turkish Competition Authority’s Android Decision

18 December, 2019
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Homepage
  • Latest News
  • News Widget
  • Privacy Policy
Wednesday, January 27, 2021
  • Login
  • Register
Globaltelconews
Advertisement
  • IT
  • Telecom
  • Mobile
  • e-Commerce
  • Fintech
  • Security
  • New Tech
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
No Result
View All Result
  • IT
  • Telecom
  • Mobile
  • e-Commerce
  • Fintech
  • Security
  • New Tech
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
No Result
View All Result
Globaltelconews
No Result
View All Result
Home GENERAL English

If Only Rating Agencies Could Talk Turkey

globaltelconews-admin by globaltelconews-admin
25 May, 2012
in English
0
1.2k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

John Lennon dreams the lack of three groups of people in the world in his famous song Imagine: religious leaders, political leaders and credit rating agencies (CRA). Some may read the last one as the financial leaders, but the greedy bunch in the Wall Street, London or Hong Kong would not dare to be that bad if the CRAs were not in their pay list to play. I am not a fan of The Economist magazine but they summarized it nicely in 2009:


    “If the past decade’s financial over-engineering was a crime, rating agencies were the getaway drivers.”

In case of Hanover Re with Moodys in 2004, it was blackmail in every language.

Believe it or not, the Wall Street was not able to pay and play the CRAs until 70s. We were, instead. Yes, we, the people as genuine investors, would pay CRAs for their reports on companies. That was a fair practice but fair is the first victim of greed. The companies that needed equity from investors and lower-interest credit from banks have started paying CRAs to rate their debt issues. The amount of checks made to CRAs ranges anywhere from a couple of thousand dollars to several millions, depending on the size of the client. There is no better example of a conflict of interest.

Enron and WorldCom had triple-A ratings by all three CARs when they collapsed in the hands of Arthur Andersen and CRAs. Even those two scandals, which came to light in 2001 and 2002, respectively, were not enough to be a wake-up call for anyone in rating agencies or the banks or the regulator, SEC. Instead of fixing their internal procedures and raising the bar, they played the three monkeys until hell broke loose. Not a single expert out of 20,000 people employed by the three CRAs had foreseen signs of another Enron or WorldCom during the next seven or eight years. Nobody in the Wall Street or SEC had, either.

It was an old man named Warren Buffett, in a small town in Nebraska, some 2000km away from the Wall Street, to notice the accounting manipulations in Freddie Mac, even before Enron went south. Now we know what he meant when he said


    Theres never just one cockroach in the kitchen

after selling all his shares in Freddie Mac. However, we should also keep in mind that this old man had acquired 15% of Moodys when it became public in 2000. Moody’s also have the top rating to Freddie Mac until Warren Buffetts warning on CNBC but downgraded the stock the next day.

In short, despite having these three crystal balls or market makers under their hands, nobody was smart, brave or decent enough to warn investors for the coming of sub-prime mortgage crisis with ripple effects all over the world, including bankruptcy of Lehman, fire-sale of Bear Stearns and Merrill Lynch, voluntary demotion of Goldman and Morgan to commercial banks, takeover of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae by the US government, collapse of Iceland and subsequent damages in the UK and Netherlands. All of these companies, banks and countries involved had the highest ratings from CRAs until the very last day. It was David Wyss, the chief economist of S&P until 2011, telling to Associated Press one month after retiring that


    “The credit agencies don’t know any more about government budgets than the guy in the street who is reading the newspaper.”

IMF calculated the loss from global recession as $4.1 trillion. That is more than five times the Turkish GDP. Compared to that, the cost of poor credit rating to Turkey is just peanuts. Suleyman Yasar of Sabah Daily calculates the difference of higher interest payments as about $6b per year. It is no small feat from local perspective. But it is also clear from the colossal losses mentioned above that Turkey is not the center of the world or the main target of CRAs.

We cannot blame CRAs for trying to run their business as usual and continue manipulating the target companies, banks and economies, possibly in coordination with certain companies and banks. Yelling at them is like charging against windmills. The financial world still operates based on their credit rating mechanism without any better alternative. What Turkey can do is to leave as little room for speculation, manipulation and destruction by CRAs as possible. We cannot kill them, ignore them or replace them. Well have to live with them.

CRAs are like the difficult teachers we need to somehow satisfy to get a good grade. Turkey is a perfect candidate to get that investment grade with rapid growth in major sectors like automotive, electronics, infrastructure, agriculture, tourism, healthcare and retail to name a few. There is a huge domestic demand and also the potential for expansion or export. Developments in highways, railways, airlines, tourism, agriculture and mining are particularly impressive. And yet, all that glitters is not gold.

We cannot blame CRAs for warning investors against dangers like state monopoly in telecoms turning into a private monopoly or privatization in electricity distribution ending up in a mess. Dozens of licenses in telecoms and hundreds of them in power sectors have become useless due to the lack of competition in the former and the absence of the rule of law in the latter. Know-who is still more important than know-how in these sectors. Situation in media sector is even worse.

There are three times more hospitals now but there is no mechanism in place to keep the good doctors in public payroll. And only a few private hospitals can match the CapEx buried into the state or university hospitals.

It is a great plan to invest in education by providing tablets to 15 million students in country. It is even a better idea to provide 15% lead to local production in bid price in order to curb the current account deficit. But it all gets blurry when it comes to selection of that local candidate. Tender rules keep changing. The latest news is that the project is exempted from public tender procedures. How would you rate this if you were S&P?

Equally important from foreign investors perspective are the political developments. There has been no civilian constitution in place for ages, and no solution to Kurdish conflict in sight. Despite all the public support in last years elections, work on the new constitution is kept behind doors and the Kurdish problem is more polarized than ever.

Looking at the last four paragraphs, one can say not much has changed in major areas in Turkey. If all true, let us not expect a change in our credit ratings either. Were almost there, thanks to the growth and stability that we experience since 2002. We are one tick below the investment grade. We just need to stamp it with democracy and transparency in western standards.

See Turkish translation of this article at : Kredi Derecelendirme Hikayesinde ne de var, uvaldz da.

Popular Posts

  • Year 2020: What is the Status of 5G Rollout Worldwide and Turkey

    Year 2020: What is the Status of 5G Rollout Worldwide and Turkey

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • EML Launches Branded Winnings Card with European Gaming customer Betsson in Sweden

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Last Exit: Revolutionize the Way Plastic is Used

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Europol Hosts 3rd Conference on Criminal Finances and Crypto Currencies

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • GardaWorld Enhances Travel Security Services with Launch of 2019 Global Mobility Risk Map

    3 shares
    Share 3 Tweet 0
  • UK Joined in European Fibre Broadband Rankings

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Year 2020: What is the Status of 5G Rollout Worldwide and Turkey

Year 2020: What is the Status of 5G Rollout Worldwide and Turkey

31 January, 2020
EML Launches Branded Winnings Card with European Gaming customer Betsson in Sweden

EML Launches Branded Winnings Card with European Gaming customer Betsson in Sweden

4 February, 2019
Last Exit: Revolutionize the Way Plastic is Used

Last Exit: Revolutionize the Way Plastic is Used

27 December, 2018
Europol Hosts 3rd Conference on Criminal Finances and Crypto Currencies

Europol Hosts 3rd Conference on Criminal Finances and Crypto Currencies

11 March, 2019

Turkish National Operating System; Gelecek Linux

0

Turkish ISP Sector Got a Breathe

0

Turkcell and Telsim Sentenced to Penalty of Record

0

Turkcell’s Return to Council Decision

0
China Liberal Education Holdings Limited Starts Higher Volume Production and Expands Domestic Sales Channels of All-in-one Machine AI-Space

China Liberal Education Holdings Limited Starts Higher Volume Production and Expands Domestic Sales Channels of All-in-one Machine AI-Space

19 December, 2020
Bell connecting Canadians at home for the holidays with free TV programming and no extra usage fees on residential Internet

Bell connecting Canadians at home for the holidays with free TV programming and no extra usage fees on residential Internet

18 December, 2020
TEMSA: Bus exports to be delivered to the heart of the European Union

TEMSA: Bus exports to be delivered to the heart of the European Union

18 December, 2020
EU tries to reshape the rules of the Internet

EU tries to reshape the rules of the Internet

17 December, 2020

Placeholder text. Slogal goes here.

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis a nulla pariatur.

Latest Posts

China Liberal Education Holdings Limited Starts Higher Volume Production and Expands Domestic Sales Channels of All-in-one Machine AI-Space

China Liberal Education Holdings Limited Starts Higher Volume Production and Expands Domestic Sales Channels of All-in-one Machine AI-Space

19 December, 2020
Bell connecting Canadians at home for the holidays with free TV programming and no extra usage fees on residential Internet

Bell connecting Canadians at home for the holidays with free TV programming and no extra usage fees on residential Internet

18 December, 2020

Navigation

  • Authors
  • Author Login
  • Author Application
  • Advertisement
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Sitemap

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

We keep your data private and share your data only with third parties that make this service possible. Read our Privacy Policy.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

© 2018 Globaltelconews.com

No Result
View All Result
  • IT
  • Telecom
  • Mobile
  • e-Commerce
  • Fintech
  • Security
  • New Tech
  • About
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy

© 2018 Globaltelconews.com

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Fill the forms below to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In